Cross Validated
2026-10-31 15:14 UTC
By anonim123
AI-113-20261031-social-media-06f1e055
Percent of Maximum Possible (POMP) vs standardized mean difference (SMD), is POMP ever defensible?
I just encountered a meta analysis that combined different pain questionnaires not using SMD which I would think reasonable, but using something called POMP. As I understood it POMP converts all of the scales into a shared 100 point scale and then treats them as comparable otherwise. To me, intuitively this sounds like just nonsense. I tried to find some text investigating this but I found nothing convincing. Intuitively I just don't see how you can compare different scales like this without explicitly accounting for the fact that one scale can have a mean at 3/10 and a huge SD, while another can have a mean at 5/10 and a tiny SD. Is POMP ever defensible?
I just encountered a meta analysis that combined different pain questionnaires not using SMD which I would think reasonable, but using something called POMP. As I understood it POMP converts all of the scales into a shared 100 point scale and then treats them as comparable otherwise. To me, intuitively this sounds like just nonsense. I tried to find some text investigating this but I found nothing convincing. Intuitively I just don't see how you can compare different scales like this without explicitly accounting for the fact that one scale can have a mean at 3/10 and a huge SD, while another can have a mean at 5/10 and a tiny SD. Is POMP ever defensible?
Full article content could not be extracted automatically. Read the original below.
Source:
Cross Validated
· stats.stackexchange.com