You can access the judgment here.
The UK High Court on October 30 dismissed legal challenges by Meta, WhatsApp, X and TikTok against information requests issued by communications regulator Ofcom under the Online Safety Act 2023. The court ruled that Ofcom had acted within its powers in demanding detailed data on content moderation and user safety, rejecting the companies’ arguments that the requests were unlawful and imposed excessive compliance burdens.
The ruling by Lord Justice Singh and Mrs Justice Collins Rice marks the first judicial review of Ofcom’s information-gathering powers under the Act.
What was the dispute about?
In February 2026, Ofcom issued notices requiring the platforms to submit data on user activity, content removals, account restrictions, exposure to harmful content, user complaints and appeals against moderation decisions. The requests also sought age-disaggregated data, including information about children’s exposure to harmful content.
The regulator sought information dating back to January 2024 to assess whether online safety was improving after the introduction of the law. The notices required companies to submit data in three phases, with deadlines in June 2026, September 2026 and March 2027.
Under the Online Safety Act, Ofcom can impose fines of up to £18 million or 10% of a company’s worldwide revenue, whichever is higher, for certain breaches. The regulator has previously fined platforms for failing to respond to information requests, including £20,000 penalties against 4chan and Im.ge in 2025.
Following months of discussions with Ofcom, the companies challenged the notices through judicial review proceedings, arguing that the regulator had exceeded its legal powers.
What did the companies argue?
Meta, X and TikTok argued that Ofcom was using its general information-gathering powers to bypass a separate transparency reporting system under the Act, which contains specific limits and safeguards.
They also questioned whether Ofcom genuinely needed the information for identifiable regulatory purposes, alleging that the regulator was collecting extensive data without sufficiently explaining how it would be used.
The companies further argued that Ofcom had failed to carry out the required assessment of the notices’ impact. TikTok separately alleged that the official responsible for issuing its notice had already made up his mind before considering the company’s objections.
A central objection concerned the cost and resources needed to comply.
X told the court that compliance could cost “millions of pounds” and require months of work by specialist staff. Meta said preparing its partial response had already involved up to 20 teams. At the same time, TikTok described its notice as one of the largest regulatory information requests it had received in the UK or EU.
What did Ofcom argue?
Ofcom maintained that the information was necessary to measure online safety risks, evaluate the effectiveness of content moderation and assess whether its regulatory measures were working.
The regulator argued that its powers under Section 100 of the Act were broad enough to collect information for monitoring and research, without linking every request to an immediate enforcement action.
It also said it had consulted the companies extensively, revised the notices to reduce compliance burdens and remained willing to consider practical difficulties, including alternative data and extended deadlines.
What did the court rule?
The court rejected the argument that Ofcom had bypassed the transparency reporting system, finding that the two mechanisms served different purposes.
“The transparency regime serves a different purpose from the information notices issued by OFCOM,” the judges said in paragraph 43, explaining that the former concerned public disclosure. At the same time, the latter allowed the regulator to collect information for its own work.
The court also upheld Ofcom’s authority to determine what information it needed, subject to judicial oversight. In paragraph 57, it said: “the question for the court is whether the assessment by OFCOM that it does need the information is a rational one.”
It rejected the challenges concerning impact assessments, alleged predetermination and failure to follow published guidance.
On proportionality, the court examined whether the benefits of the information requests justified the additional burden on the companies.
It found that although the platforms had described substantial compliance costs, they had not provided sufficient evidence showing how much of that burden arose specifically from the notices, rather than their existing regulatory obligations.
In paragraph 161, the judges stated: “It does not sufficiently identify the necessary baselines or differential resource impact.”
The court added: “No finding of a lack of overall fairness is therefore sustainable on the materials before the court.”
The judges granted permission to pursue the proportionality challenges but dismissed them on their merits. They also found no breach of the companies’ rights under the Human Rights Act.
Meta’s other legal challenges against Ofcom
The ruling comes amid several other disputes between Meta and Ofcom. Meta has separately challenged the regulator’s decision to classify WhatsApp and Instagram as Category 1 services, which face additional obligations under the Online Safety Act. It has also challenged Ofcom’s method of calculating regulatory fees and penalties. These cases are separate from the dispute over information requests.
The ruling leaves Ofcom’s information notices intact and affirms its authority under Section 100 to seek data for online safety monitoring, subject to applicable legal safeguards.
Read more: