Police have sent X legal requests against the Internet Freedom Foundation (IFF), SFLC.in and @geoblockedindia. None of the X notifications they have shared names the law they allegedly violated.

  • @geoblockedindia: X sent the account four notifications about requests from “Indian Police”, Uttar Pradesh Police (Cyber Crime), Telangana Police (Intelligence Department) and Delhi Police (Cyber Crime), SFLC.in said. Telangana Police alleged that the entire account violates Indian law, @geoblockedindia posted. Uttar Pradesh Police flagged its post about the blocking of 26 Reddit URLs across 18 subreddits, according to the account.
  • SFLC.in: X told SFLC.in that “Indian Police” alleged its post about the first notice violated Indian law.
  • IFF: X sent IFF a similar notification about its post on the first notice, @geoblockedindia said.

The requests followed two notices that claimed to have been issued on behalf of the Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh (RSS). The notices asked the three organisations to stop criticising and documenting the government’s blocking orders.

What is @geoblockedindia?

The account posts details of content that platforms block in India on government orders. On October 24, it posted the order under which Reddit blocked posts in India, mostly concerning the India-China border. Uttar Pradesh Police flagged that post.

Section 69A of the Information Technology (IT) Act allows the government to block online content. The government keeps these orders confidential. Reddit made the order public by filing it with the Lumen Database, which collects takedown requests.

What did the notices demand?

The first notice reached IFF’s legal team at 9:54 PM on October 29, IFF said in a blog post. It asked the three organisations to:

  • Stop opposing the government’s blocking directions.
  • Stop documenting restricted content.
  • Stop posting details of geo-blocked posts.
  • Confirm in writing that they would comply within seven days.

The notice warned of “appropriate legal action”. It also objected to SFLC.in’s Free Speech Tracker, saying the tracker “effectively guides people” to blocked content through virtual private networks (VPNs).

The covering email said the notice was “issued on behalf of Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh”. An unnamed “Authorised Signatory” signed it. The listed office address is a residential flat in outer Delhi, and the notice asked recipients to send replies to a free Proton Mail address. IFF has published the redacted notice.

The second notice arrived on November 1 from “an advocate purportedly acting on behalf of the RSS”, SFLC.in said. It stated that the matter had been taken up by the Akhil Bharatiya Adhivakta Parishad, which SFLC.in described as “the RSS’s legal and advocacy wing”. It also said complaints had been filed in several states and requests had been made to block IFF’s X accounts and suspend the organisations, IFF said in a statement on X.

What do the X notifications say?

“The notification does not identify the requesting law enforcement agency, specify the legal provisions allegedly violated, or provide a copy of the order/request,” SFLC.in said.

“@X has, in other instances, informed users of the requesting authority and the legal basis for takedown requests, and even shared copies of the orders received. We have not received any such information in this case,” it added.

SFLC.in asked X to “disclose the order, identify the requesting authority, and specify the legal basis for the takedown requests.” Its post remains accessible. It also asked X Corp India to “clarify the authenticity and status of this notification.”

Are the notices genuine?

“As many, including us, have indicated, they may be fake,” IFF said. However, it disclosed the notices to its community “due to their plausible nature”.

Some RSS office-bearers have said on X that the first notice is not authentic. IFF said it wrote to the RSS at its official address after receiving the first notice, asking “whether it authorised either”.

What did IFF and SFLC.in say?

In its reply, IFF said the first notice does not cite any illegal act or provision of law. It said Article 19(1)(a) of the Constitution, which guarantees freedom of speech, protects criticism of government directions and the documentation of blocking orders.

“Documenting censorship and challenging it in court is not an offence. It is what the Constitution expects of us,” IFF said. “We will not be intimidated by threats, whoever sends them, and we will not be bullied into silence.”

“If it is a legal demand that results in a takedown, we will contest it,” IFF said about the request against its post. It said it had assisted 86 people in the past three weeks whose accounts were suspended or whose posts were withheld in India. “That work is the reason these notices exist as an attempt to bully and harass us,” it said.

SFLC.in said it would continue maintaining the Free Speech Tracker. Its documentation “helps us understand censorship patterns, brings transparency to content moderation practices, and helps individuals question decisions that affect their online speech,” it said.

How much is being blocked?

SFLC.in’s tracker recorded about 268 content restrictions and 83 account restrictions in the first 29 days of October, MediaNama found. Instagram accounted for 174 content restrictions and 59 account restrictions.

Questions the requests leave open:

  • Which law: Which law do the police say the three organisations violated?
  • Which police: Which police force sent the “Indian Police” requests against IFF’s and SFLC.in’s posts?
  • Telangana’s request: Does Telangana Police want X to block the entire @geoblockedindia account?
  • The notices: Who sent the notices, and did the RSS authorise either of them?

Also Read: