Regarding your first point, you say that "As far as I can tell, nobody's trying to build this", but it seems that Stop The AI Race (which you know from being a speaker a couple of times at our events) matches your description pretty closely. If not, I'd be curious what specifically you think we're not doing or doing wrong compared to that hypothetical org.

In particular, regarding having nowhere to point people for a movement with leaders organizing marches, we're organizing a protest on Nov 14 that will happen in multiple cities and countries at the same time, explicitly asking for an AI Treaty. More info here: aitreatymarch.org.

Further, I think it's important for it to avoid taking a stance on other AI issues: There's a lot of people who hate AI's effect on artists, and people who hate AI's effects on the education system, and people who hate AI's effects on the environment; and there's also people who like current AI as a technology but still don't want to go extinct from it; and we should all be able to team up when it comes to averting extinction.

I resonate in principle with the idea that averting extinction should be at the core of what we're focusing on, and that taking a stance on a bunch of other issues could alienate folks.

However, we might disagree on whether a movement trying to prevent AI extinction should at least mention that these different causes are not as separate as people think.

For instance, when people are worried about their livelihoods, the impact of AI on their kids' education, or the use of AI in war, I want to tell them that stopping the insane market race to build superintelligence (aka stopping frontier model development, with teams working on more powerful models moving to alignment instead) also addresses their concerns by making sure the situation doesn't get even worse (fewer jobs, even more advanced AI in the military, etc.).

There should exist an org that can ally with the folks who hate datacenters on account of their water usage, when it comes to lobbying for an end to dangerous AI training runs, but that does not require this belief among its members. A group that focuses narrowly on averting extinction, and that serves as a warm and friendly ally to all those who will oppose that particular segment of AI, as part of a broader coalition that not all members will agree with.

Being a warm and friendly ally is what Stop The AI Race aimed for at the July 11 protest. Food & Water Watch joined the coalition (for "The AI Protest") and gave a speech, so they were our ally, but Stop The AI Race's DNA has always been about the risk from AI extinction. When we were outside OpenAI's office for eight weeks in the Bay Area and one month in NYC, or doing the hunger strike to stop the ai race outside GDM, extinction was explicitly mentioned.

Members don't need to share views to agree about our goal. The goal of Stop The AI Race is to stop racing ahead. We're agnostic about the reasoning people have for ending up with that goal, as long as folks agree with that being a valuable goal to have (whether you think that AI should eventually resume or not).

Extinction 1) is what many of the most active folks care about, especially the ones who spent weeks outside OpenAI’s office, and 2) is at the center of our message, but caring about it is not something we require from everyone who joins.

My belief is that it's important for there to exist such a movement that avoids the "omnicause attractor" (of being attended only by people who also pick some particular side about environmental issues or middle eastern diplomacy issues or whatever)

Stop The AI Race is nonpartisan. Republicans have joined our protests, and we've invited right-wing groups to speak. We've also been reaching out to religious groups more traditionally associated with the right to build long-term coalitions there.