ZDNET’s key takeaways

  • You can use a browser-based VPN or a dedicated client.
  • I tested four browsers with free VPNs against Proton VPN.
  • Only one browser returned less desirable results.

For many people, a VPN is crucial for privacy and security, especially if you want to foil trackers that use your information to create a profile that can then be used or sold. 

Are free browser VPNs any good?

I decided to test how well browser-based VPNs performed compared to my desktop VPN client of choice, Proton VPN. First, I used Whatsmyipaddress.com to assess how well they obfuscated my IP address. I also used BrowserLeak.com to check whether the VPN leaked DNS entries and to check whether a device’s DNS requests exposed its real location or internet service provider.

Also: Half of all cyberattacks start in your browser: 10 essential tips for staying safe

To compare, I then tested the Proton VPN client on MacOS (because the Linux app still doesn’t install properly) with the same tools.

Note: I only tested browsers with free VPN services and used the Extended DNS Leak Test. Let’s get on with the testing.

1. Firefox

Yes, the latest iteration of the Firefox browser includes a free-to-use VPN. It’s also very easy to use. Just open Firefox and click VPN (near the right side of the toolbar). From the pop-up, click Turn On VPN. Here are the results of the test with the Firefox VPN enabled:

  • IP address check: Passed. IP address registered as 63.245.220.16, and the region was Chicago.
  • DNS leak test: Passed. All IP addresses went through Fastly in Chicago with no exposed information.

2. Opera

Yes, Opera has a VPN as well. While Opera’s VPN isn’t nearly as easy to use as Firefox’s, it’s been around considerably longer, so it’s had more time to evolve and improve. You enable the VPN through the Opera Settings window, so you don’t need to enable/disable it on the fly. Here’s how Opera’s VPN tests went:

  • IP address check: Passed. Whatsmyipaddress.com showed my IP address as 77.111.246.40 and my location as Linköping, Sweden.
  • DNS leak test: Passed. Domain queries went through either Google or i3D.net, so no leakage.

3. Aloha Browser

Aloha is one of the more secure web browsers on the list, but it’s just as easy to use as Firefox. Click the VPN icon to the left of the address bar and then click Connect. Once connected, the browser is ready for private use. Here are the results of the test:

  • IP address check: Passed. Whatsmyipaddress.com showed my IP address as 193.135.174.133 and my location as Sofia, Bulgaria.
  • DNS leak test: Passed. All domain queries went through Cloudflare, so no leakage.

4. Vivaldi

Vivaldi actually uses Proton VPN as its “built-in” VPN server, and you can sign up in one of two ways: either with your Proton VPN account or through your Vivaldi account. If you sign up with a Vivaldi account (which is free), Proton VPN is also free. How did it fare?

  • IP address check: Passed. Whatsmyipaddress.com showed my IP address as 37.19.200.3, but Vivaldi did not hide my location. To get around this, all I had to do was click Change Location in the VPN drop-down. I found that, as long as the VPN server was not in the United States, my location was masked.
  • DNS leak test: Passed. All DNS queries went through DataCamp Limited, so no leakage.

The desktop client comparison

Now it’s time to run the same tests using Proton VPN. I used Proton VPN Quick Connect. Here are the results:

  • IP address check: Passed. Whatsmyipaddress.com showed my IP address as 149.40.58.151 and my location as Dallas, Texas.
  • DNS leak test: Passed. All DNS queries went through DataCamp Limited, so no leakage.

My conclusion

For basic usage, every browser passed the DNS leak test with flying colors. For the location/IP address obfuscation test, all browser VPNs could mask my IP address, but Vivaldi did not obfuscate my location without an extra step.

Also: 10+ VPN tricks and tips I recommend to everyone

With those results in mind, the built-in VPNs for Firefox, Opera, and Aloha perform as well as the dedicated VPN client for web use. However, if you want the most privacy and Vivaldi is your browser of choice, the dedicated client is your best option.

The key is that only a client-based VPN works with all your network traffic. If you demand maximum privacy, your best bet is a dedicated VPN client. If you only use your browser (and no other online apps), you could trust Firefox, Opera, Aloha, and Vivaldi as well as a dedicated app.

In my opinion, the dedicated VPN app is the way to go for extra peace of mind. If you use email, streaming services, or any other app that needs network connectivity outside of a browser, use the dedicated client to be safe.