“There is no justice for judges who are prey to such social media propaganda,” the Allahabad High Court said in an order on October 29.
A bench of Justices Ajay Bhanot and Divesh Chandra Samant called for revisiting free speech laws to tackle fake news. “Many first principles of constitutional law on freedom of speech have to be recast to adapt fundamental freedoms to this new form of technology,” the bench said, Bar & Bench reported.
The bench also recommended registering a first information report (FIR) against those behind what it called false posts about the court.
What did the court say?
“An entire narrative of falsehoods and half truths was developed and propagated on the social media platforms to bring the High Court into disrepute and irreparably assault the constitutional stature and glorious standing of the Allahabad High Court. The false narrative has created disaffection against the High Court, and impeded the process of law.”
- Reputations: The bench said judges build their reputations over a lifetime, while social media falsehoods can destroy them in seconds.
- Wider threat: It said fake narratives can turn people against constitutional institutions, paralyse their functioning and create anarchy.
- Next steps: “Hence the Court will have to take measures to protect the judicial process from fake social media outpourings which are interfering in the process of law in the facts of this case,” the bench said.
- Goebbels: “Social media had a field day and played its role of a Goebbilian institution to the hilt in this case,” it said.
Do judges need special protection?
“I don’t see why judges need to be in a position of privilege when it comes to legitimate critique. Their decisions impact people. And they should be open to critique,” MediaNama founder Nikhil Pahwa said.
Judges already have remedies under existing laws:
- Defamation: Like any citizen, judges can file a civil suit for defamation or a criminal complaint under Section 356 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita (BNS), 2023.
- Contempt: Courts can punish speech that “scandalises or tends to scandalise” a court as criminal contempt under Section 2(c) of the Contempt of Courts Act, 1971.
- The Constitution: Article 19(2) already allows the State to restrict free speech “in relation to contempt of court, defamation or incitement to an offence.”
What led to the order?
On October 28, lawyers vandalised Justice Bhanot’s courtroom, hurling chairs and toppling shelves, ThePrint reported. They also assaulted court staff and government lawyers, according to Bar & Bench.
The protest followed a hearing held a day earlier. Justice Bhanot reportedly ordered an advocate to be jailed following a dispute over the advocate’s seat with a superintendent of police. The Allahabad High Court Bar Association wrote to Chief Justice Arun Bhansali, alleging that the advocate had been ill-treated. It later called for a boycott of Justice Bhanot’s court, Organiser reported.
The bench denied the allegations. It said the bar body had made false imputations and used provocative language in its letter.
What have courts said about online criticism of judges before?
- Delhi High Court (June 2026): A bench of Justices Neena Bansal Krishna and Madhu Jain heard a contempt case against a man who called a sitting judge a murderer on social media. The bench said platforms “can also not be silent spectators and wait for directions from the Courts.” It ordered the removal of his posts within 24 hours and the blocking of his accounts. It also said fair criticism of judicial orders is permissible, but attributing corruption or improper motives to judges without basis is not.
- Madras High Court (July 2025): “Time has come to regulate the level of discourse on social media,” a bench of Justices GR Swaminathan and K Rajasekar said. It was hearing a contempt case against an advocate who accused Justice Swaminathan of caste bias in YouTube interviews.
- Kerala High Court (June 2025): In his farewell speech, Justice PB Suresh Kumar called for a law regulating online criticism of the judiciary. “These social media posts are often made without even a basic understanding of the law or even the facts,” he said.
- Andhra Pradesh High Court (November 2021): In contempt proceedings against 49 people, the court ordered Facebook, Instagram, Twitter and YouTube to take down posts criticising its judges. Those charged included a Member of Parliament (MP) and a Member of the Legislative Assembly (MLA) from the YSR Congress Party (YSRCP). “Absence of pre-screening and control of the intermediaries enable the users to successfully upload any material,” the court said.
- Supreme Court (August 2020): The court held lawyer Prashant Bhushan guilty of criminal contempt over two tweets about the judiciary and fined him Rs 1.
How has social media treated other judges?
Former Chief Justice of India (CJI) DY Chandrachud
- Trolling (March 2023): He was trolled while heading the bench hearing the Maharashtra government crisis case. Congress MP Vivek Tankha, along with 12 other Opposition leaders, wrote to President Droupadi Murmu, calling it “a brazen case of interference with the course of justice.”
- Criticism from a former judge (October 2026): “Chief Justice Chandrachud did not live up to my expectations of him,” former Supreme Court judge Sanjay Kishan Kaul said in an interview with The Wire, according to its post.
- Criticism from a journalist (October 2026): Journalist Saurav Das published a profile of him in The Caravan titled “Performative Justice: The Equivocations of DY Chandrachud.”
- Abuse (November 2026): One X user replied to Bar & Bench’s post about the Allahabad High Court order with a Hindi sexual slur targeting him.
CJI Surya Kant
- The “cockroach” remark (May 2026): “There are youngsters like cockroaches, who don’t get any employment and don’t have any place in the profession,” he said in court on May 15. He added that “some of them become social media” and “start attacking everyone.” The remark trended on X, prompting users to launch the satirical Cockroach Janta Party, Outlook reported.
- His response: He said the next day that sections of the media had misquoted him and that he had meant people with “fake or bogus degrees.” On May 25, petitioners sought a Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) probe into the party, but he declined an urgent hearing. “Don’t take it so sentimentally,” he told their counsel, The Quint reported.
- The party’s X account: X withheld the account in India on May 21. The Ministry of Electronics and Information Technology (MeitY) had ordered the block under Section 69A of the Information Technology (IT) Act, 2000. The government told the Delhi High Court that it had blocked the account as a precaution before the NEET re-test (the National Eligibility cum Entrance Test for medical admissions). The court ordered X to restore the account on July 7.
- A fake post (May 2026): An X account attributed a casteist remark to him. His office called it “an act of utter dishonesty, deliberate social provocation, and contempt for constitutional values,” LiveLaw reported.
- On online commentary (December 2025): “I am a very tough person to be handled,” he said. “There is a wrong impression that somebody can browbeat the court.”
Also Read: