Republicans can lose up to three seats today and still keep the Senate majority. Any further losses, however, carry immense consequences.
Most in the party are already clocking North Carolina as lost to the Democrats. Losing the Senate would deprive Republicans of control over President Donald Trump’s nominees — including lifetime judicial appointments.
And provided the House flips Democratic, Republicans could see a procession of impeachment trials for Cabinet members — and perhaps even the president.
“The two oldest members of the Supreme Court are both Republican [appointees]. We want to make sure that if one of them decides to retire, or both, in the next two years, that President Trump can make an appointment that will get confirmed in the United States Senate,” Senate Majority Whip John Barrasso, R-Wyo., told Semafor on Monday amid a day of campaigning in Iowa.
Republicans can quickly table impeachment trials with a simple majority if they keep Senate control; just two years ago, a Democratic majority dismissed the impeachment of then-Homeland Security Secretary Alejandro Mayorkas. Next year, if Democrats claim the majority in both chambers, the GOP can’t expect quick dismissals.
“We’re going to need to be able to make sure that those are dealt with quickly in the Senate and are not allowed to be dragged out, which is what you’d have with a Democrat majority,” Barrasso added.
The national mood is poor, and Republicans are fighting it out deep in red territory. They are hoping a pair of eleventh-hour dramas in Alaska and Michigian — and their most battle-hardened incumbent — will help bail out their embattled Senate majority.
Republicans’ best pickup opportunity at the start of the cycle has faded away in Georgia. But GOP leaders see Democratic Rep. Haley Stevens’ surprise endorsement of Republican Mike Rogers as fueling their best chance in Michigan since their last Senate win in 1994.
Stevens’ endorsement “brings more energy and more attention to that race, and it’s going to help in Michigan,” Barrasso said. “That is going to be a positive influence for the Republicans in the race tomorrow, and in turn I believe is going to generate more turnout and more votes for Mike Rogers.”
The last batch of Michigan polls still show Democrat Abdul El-Sayed ahead of Rogers, though they won’t take into account Stevens’ stunning turn over the weekend. If Republicans somehow flip the Michigan seat, Democrats would have to net five pick-ups elsewhere, which would mean winning a majority of races in eight GOP-held states: North Carolina, Ohio, Texas, Maine, Alaska, Kansas, South Carolina and Iowa.
Alaska has been one of Democrats’ core focuses since the start of the year, and the race still looks close. Republicans are praying that enough Alaskans saw The New York Times’ story on Democrat Mary Peltola’s campaign allies working to recruit a spoiler candidate who might siphon votes from GOP Sen. Dan Sullivan, R-Alaska.
“The more people that know about the situation, I think the more it’s going to help Sen. Dan Sullivan. I believe he wins the race,” Barrasso said.
Asked if Peltola would be seated if she wins, Barrasso demurred: “We’re not there yet. I believe Dan Sullivan is going to win.” He also predicted GOP Sen. Susan Collins would defeat Democrat Troy Jackson in Maine, holding a seat she has occupied since winning it in 1996.
Barrasso has been to Kentucky, Iowa, Michigan, Texas, and Ohio over the past few days. He said that Trump’s rallies are critical to stoking turnout by the GOP base in a cycle that’s typically brutal for modern presidents. “Nobody can get out a crowd or energize a crowd like President Trump,” Barrasso said.