AI use in academic research is not misconduct, UAE expert explains
Using artificial intelligence in academic research is not academic misconduct, but submitting unverified AI-generated information, including fabricated references and fictitious court judgments, can undermine academic integrity, a UAE legal expert has warned.
Dr Ammar Ali, a legal consultant specialising in AI governance , said the key issue was not whether researchers used AI, but whether they took responsibility for checking the accuracy of its output.
Researchers who rely on AI-generated material without verification risk compromising the credibility of their work, particularly when it contains non-existent academic sources or inaccurate legal references.
Universities must establish clear AI policies
Under Article 16, Clause 9, of Federal Decree-Law No. 31 of 2025 on Higher Education and Scientific Research, higher education institutions in the UAE are required to uphold institutional governance, transparency and disclosure.
These obligations include managing risks, protecting academic integrity and ensuring the quality of decision-making.
Dr Ali said universities' responsibilities extend beyond identifying academic violations and imposing disciplinary penalties. They must also introduce clear, proactive policies governing the responsible use of AI in research and education.
These policies should specify students' and researchers' obligations and establish procedures for checking the accuracy and reliability of AI-generated content.
The aim, he said, should be to encourage technological innovation without compromising academic standards, while ensuring that disciplinary procedures are fair and penalties proportionate to the seriousness of any violation.
UNESCO calls for human oversight
The need for human supervision is also highlighted in UNESCO's 2023 guidance on generative AI in education and research.
Dr Ali pointed to sections 4.2 and 4.3, which address the protection of human agency and the monitoring and validation of generative AI systems. The guidance stresses the importance of verifying the reliability and suitability of AI tools for educational and research purposes.
The European commission's 2022 ethical guidelines on the use of artificial intelligence and data in teaching and learning identify four fundamental principles: human agency, fairness, humanity and justified choice.
Human agency is particularly important because it ensures that people retain control over decisions and remain accountable when using AI systems.
Researchers remain responsible for their work
Dr Ali said researchers must not treat AI-generated information as automatically reliable or allow technology to replace independent thinking and human judgement.
This is particularly important when preparing scientific research, assessing academic work and making decisions that could affect academic outcomes.
The principles also reinforce the importance of transparency, accountability, human oversight and data protection.
He stressed that responsibility must be shared between researchers and educational institutions. Researchers must verify the accuracy of information and references, while universities must establish clear rules for AI use and ensure fair investigations when academic violations are suspected.
Any disciplinary action must also be proportionate to the nature and seriousness of the violation.
"AI governance in education does not mean restricting innovation. It means ensuring that AI is used in a way that protects academic integrity and reinforces human responsibility for scientific outputs," Dr Ali said.