X told the Delhi High Court that its internal investigation had found that someone impersonating the Delhi Police had sent the takedown notices against the Internet Freedom Foundation (IFF) and Software Freedom Law Center (SFLC.in). It also said that it had filed a complaint with the Delhi Police against the impostor, according to the court proceedings attended by MediaNama.

After X clarified to the Delhi High Court that the notices were sent by an impostor and that it had filed a complaint with the Delhi Police, Justice Amit Mahajan disposed of the petitions.

What X told the court:

Appearing before Justice Amit Mahajan, X’s counsel said the platform had not acted on the notices. “We received the notice. In terms of transparency, we told them that we have received this. We didn’t take action,” the counsel said.

“It turns out this was somebody playing an impostor, somebody impersonating Delhi Police who has sent this… We are not actioning this request because it’s an illegal request. It’s not from Delhi Police. We filed a complaint last night with Delhi Police.” — X’s counsel

X’s counsel asked the court to also note that X had approached the Delhi Police to investigate the impersonation. An advocate representing the Delhi Police also attended the hearing but did not make any submissions.

What IFF and SFLC.in argued:

Senior Advocate Akhil Sibal appeared for both organisations and told the court that they had doubted the authenticity of the notices and had written to the authorities seeking confirmation. “But if it is genuine, My Lords, it’s most troubling,” he said.

He read out X’s message to the petitioners, dated November 3, which stated: “In the interest of transparency, we are writing to inform you that X has received requests from the Delhi Police regarding your X account.”

The attached “Receipt of illegal content report” named the Special Commissioner of Police (Crime), Delhi Police, as the sender. Sibal said SFLC.in had emailed the address mentioned in the notice to ask whether it was genuine, but the email “bounced back”. Read more about it here.

He also said that the legal notice sent in the name of the Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh (RSS) did not contain any lawyer’s details or a signature. The notices accused the organisations of defaming the RSS under Section 356 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita (BNS), which covers criminal defamation. Sibal told the court that defamation is “non-cognizable” and rhetorically asked how the police could send such a notice.

Sibal told the court that the Delhi Police had not said anything in the matter. Before the hearing, as noted by MediaNama, IFF and SFLC.in said they had filed the writ petition before the Delhi High Court because the Delhi Police had not responded to their queries.

After X stated that the notices were, in fact, fake and had been sent by an impostor, Sibal told the court that X’s statement could be recorded and the petitions disposed of. The court recorded X’s statement and closed the petitions. According to IFF, the court gave both organisations the liberty to approach it afresh if any action was taken.

Online impersonation and the free speech problem: 

While the use of email identities that appear to belong to the Delhi Police is threatening and bizarre, this impersonation issue also raises concerns about the misuse of copyright tools on intermediary social media platforms. Some entities impersonate creators by either claiming that content uploaded by the original creator belongs to them or falsely claiming ownership of someone else’s content.

The Delhi High Court is examining the copyright tools of intermediaries. MediaNama has also documented instances of fake copyright notices issued to content creators, particularly concerning critical speech, political speech, and speech about billionaire Anant Ambani.

Also read