Meta, Google and TikTok have filed separate lawsuits challenging a California law that seeks to restrict potentially addictive social media features for users under 16. The companies sued California Attorney General Rob Bonta on November 4, arguing that the law violates their First Amendment rights by interfering with how they select, organise and display online content.
California Governor Gavin Newsom signed Assembly Bill 1709 (AB 1709) in September 2026. The law, scheduled to take effect on January 1, 2027, prohibits platforms from offering personalised feeds and autoplay features to users under 16, even with parental consent.
Platforms must take reasonable measures to prevent minors from accessing these features and delete accounts of under-16 users who continue receiving them. Violations could attract penalties of up to $50,000 per affected user.
All three companies argue that the law interferes with editorial decisions protected by the First Amendment and conflicts with Section 230 of the Communications Decency Act, which protects online platforms from certain liabilities involving third-party content. They have asked federal courts to block its enforcement.
What Google argues
Google and YouTube argue that California’s law takes decision-making power away from parents and interferes with YouTube’s ability to recommend content appropriate for younger users.
“Assembly Bill 1709 (“AB 1709” or “the Act”) wrests control of what kids watch from their parents and gives it to the State,” the companies said in their lawsuit.
Google argues that personalised recommendations are editorial decisions protected under the First Amendment. It says these recommendations help children find relevant videos among billions of uploads and that removing them could increase their exposure to inappropriate content.
The lawsuit also argues that Section 230 protects platforms’ decisions about which third-party videos to recommend and how to display them.
“[M]atching users with content is publishing conduct, even when the user has not requested the content,” Google said, citing a federal appeals court ruling.
Google further argues that autoplay allows educational videos and other related content to play in sequence. It notes that YouTube already disables autoplay by default for users under 18 and allows parents to turn it off entirely for children under 13.
The company contends that California cannot justify an outright ban when parents already have tools to control their children’s viewing experiences.
What Meta argues
Meta argues that the law allows California to interfere with its editorial decisions on Facebook, Instagram and Threads, including how it recommends and displays user-generated content.
“AB 1709 is California’s latest attempt to flout that fundamental principle and appoint the State as the editor, curator, and controller of online speech,” Meta said in its lawsuit.
The company argues that the First Amendment protects platforms’ decisions about organising and distributing third-party content, just as it protects editorial choices made by traditional publishers.
Meta also challenges the law under Section 230, arguing that recommendations, autoplay and decisions to remove user accounts are protected publishing activities.
It further argues that the restrictions are excessively broad because they apply to all users under 16, regardless of how much time they spend online or their individual circumstances.
Meta says it plans to introduce a default cumulative two-hour time limit for minors using Facebook and Instagram. Parents or guardians will be able to override the limit. The company also plans to offer options to turn off personalised feeds and autoplay.
What TikTok argues
TikTok argues that the law threatens its For You feed, which uses algorithms to select and arrange videos for individual users. It says these decisions constitute protected expression under the First Amendment.
“TikTok thus creates a ‘distinctive expressive product’ every time it delivers a curated collection of videos to a user,” the company said in its lawsuit, citing a 2024 Supreme Court ruling.
TikTok argues that California has not established a sufficient legal justification for restricting these features or shown that the restrictions are necessary to protect children.
“Here, the State cannot link the challenged provisions of the Act to substantial or compelling governmental interests,” the lawsuit states.
The company also argues that the law restricts more expression than necessary and disregards existing safeguards, including its Family Pairing feature, which allows parents to manage screen time, privacy settings and content restrictions.
TikTok points out that it is already challenging California’s Senate Bill 976, which restricts personalised feeds for users under 18 without parental consent. Unlike that law, AB 1709 prohibits the targeted features for users under 16 even when parents approve.
TikTok’s appeal in its legal challenge to the earlier law is pending before the US Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit.
Why are digital rights organisations concerned?
The Electronic Frontier Foundation (EFF) has warned that enforcing the restrictions could require platforms to collect more personal information to determine users’ ages, affecting adults as well as children.
“AB 1709 compels platforms to collect even more information from every user, invading everyone’s privacy and frustrating our ability to remain anonymous online,” EFF Associate Director of State Affairs Rindala Alajaji said.
The organisation also argues that restricting teenagers’ access to social media could limit their ability to access information, participate in public discussions and organise social movements.
The lawsuits come amid growing scrutiny of social media’s impact on children. In August 2026, Meta agreed to a settlement of up to $18 billion to resolve child-safety claims brought by 29 US states.
Governments elsewhere have also introduced restrictions. Australia banned social media access for users under 16 in December 2025, while France’s top court struck down a similar law over freedom of expression concerns.
Bonta’s office said it is reviewing the lawsuits and remains committed to “defending California’s commonsense laws to protect kids online.”
Read more: