The National Payments Corporation of India (NPCI) informed the Supreme Court that its new Merchant Discount Rate (MDR) on UPI payments is both lawful and necessary. NPCI also stated that merchants and UPI apps cannot pass this charge on to consumers, according to a LiveLaw report.

In a counter-affidavit dated November 3, NPCI clarified that the framework imposes a charge of up to 0.4% only on person-to-merchant (P2M) payments exceeding Rs 2,000. NPCI also confirmed that UPI app providers are not permitted to levy platform fees or additional charges on UPI payments.

What the charge covers, and what it doesn’t

  • Where MDR applies: P2M transactions exceeding Rs 2,000, with the charge capped at 0.4%.
  • Where it doesn’t: Person-to-person transfers and transactions involving small merchants in the P2PM category (those receiving up to Rs 1 lakh in monthly UPI credits) remain free.
  • Scale, according to NPCI: About 70% of UPI transactions are person-to-person transfers, while about 96% of P2M transactions are for Rs 2,000 or less. NPCI says MDR will therefore apply to only about 4% of merchant transactions.
  • Comparison with cards: NPCI says the 0.4% ceiling is significantly lower than the charges imposed by other payment systems on credit and debit card transactions.
  • Status: The original circular set October 15 as the implementation date. However, NPCI says implementation has been postponed. The affidavit, as reported, does not specify a new date.

NPCI’s position on pass-through to customers

NPCI maintains that the prohibition on passing MDR on to customers is binding and not merely a policy assurance. The affidavit states that if a payer bank or UPI app (Payer PSP or TPAP) violates this directive, it would breach its service-level agreements with NPCI, which require compliance with all NPCI circulars. Such violations may invite compliance action or termination of UPI membership. NPCI considers the petitioner’s concern about an indirect burden on consumers to be unfounded.

On the possibility of merchants increasing prices, NPCI argues that a charge applicable only to certain transactions above a specified threshold provides little incentive for merchants to revise prices for their entire customer base. It describes the concern about a “quiet revision of prices” as misconceived.

Why NPCI says the charge is needed

NPCI argues that zero-MDR created a structural gap between the costs of operating UPI and the revenue available to meet them. According to NPCI, this has restricted investment in infrastructure resilience, cybersecurity, fraud prevention, and customer services for a system that processes billions of transactions every month.

It cites the Parliamentary Standing Committee on Finance to support its position:

  • The Committee’s Thirty-Second Report on Demands for Grants for 2026-27 found that the Rs 2,000 crore allocation to offset zero-MDR costs covers only 11% of industry costs and 14% of potential MDR collections.
  • The Committee recommended that the Department of Financial Services explore a self-reliant, tiered revenue model.
  • The Finance Ministry’s response to the Committee estimated industry operating costs at Rs 20,700 crore, against the Rs 2,000 crore allocation.

NPCI also states that it will fund a dedicated UPI adoption programme for small merchants with an annual turnover of up to Rs 20 lakh. The programme will receive 5% of each entity’s MDR share, excluding specified industry-programme categories. NPCI maintains that exempting small merchants from MDR and supporting their digital inclusion does not mean excluding them from the framework.

The legal arguments

Statutory basis: NPCI says the Reserve Bank of India (RBI) authorised it in August 2016 to operate UPI under Section 4 of the Payment and Settlement Systems Act, 2007. It relies on Sections 20 and 21 of the Act to establish its authority to set and disclose charges.

Section 10A amendment: The petition challenges the amendment to Section 10A, introduced through the Taxation and Other Laws (Amendment) Act, 2026. NPCI argues that the amendment neither imposes MDR nor grants it the authority to set rates. Instead, it specifies the payment modes exempt from charges, leaving the authority to impose charges on other modes with authorised system operators.

The Centre’s September 14 notification identified two exempt payment modes: RuPay debit card transactions, without any value limit, and UPI transactions of up to Rs 2,000. NPCI issued its circular on the revised MDR on September 15, 2026.

Nature of MDR: NPCI describes MDR as a commercial charge shared among UPI participants, rather than a tax or government fee.

Fundamental rights: NPCI argues that, since it is not considered “State” under Article 12 of the Constitution, the petitioner cannot invoke Articles 14 and 19(1)(g) against it. NPCI also defends the framework, stating that its classifications based on transaction value, merchant category, and merchant size rest on clear distinctions. According to NPCI, these classifications support a sustainable, secure, and inclusive UPI ecosystem. It maintains that the framework is neither arbitrary nor an unreasonable restriction on trade.

Also read: