Access the order here:

The Karnataka High Court has dismissed a request to quash criminal proceedings against five men accused of using a woman’s Instagram photograph in connection with an obscene video. The video, along with her Instagram ID and contact details, was allegedly circulated in WhatsApp groups.

In its order, the court held that a photograph posted on social media “for ordinary and legitimate purposes cannot be treated as consent to its use in obscene material or to the circulation of such material among others”.

Justice Suraj Govindaraj passed the order on October 12, 2026. LiveLaw reported it on November 4.

The reasoning in the case appears to be at odds with how India’s data protection law treats a photograph of this kind. Under the Digital Personal Data Protection Act, 2023 (DPDP Act), personal data that a person has made publicly available herself does not fall within the Act’s ambit. Therefore, photographs posted by individuals on Instagram would fall outside its protection. However, the court only examined the use of the photograph, so the question of its public availability did not arise.

What was the case about?

  • The complaint: In March 2020, a college lecturer in Dakshina Kannada complained that her Instagram ID and a photograph from her account were being used to circulate an obscene video in WhatsApp groups created by a group called “Bad Boys”. She said she began receiving messages on her Instagram account after the video was circulated.
  • The charges: Police registered a case under Section 66C (identity theft) and Section 67 (publishing or transmitting obscene material) of the Information Technology Act, 2000. They filed a charge sheet on July 17, 2024. The case is pending before a magistrate’s court in Puttur.
  • The defence: The petitioners’ counsel argued that the woman in the Instagram photograph and the person in the video were different, and therefore the offences had not been made out.

What did the court say about consent?

The court held:

“The use of a publicly available photograph does not, by itself, authorise another person to misuse it, create an obscene or indecent video by associating it with the photograph, or circulate the resulting material along with the woman’s identity and contact details.”

It added that the effect of such conduct “cannot be assessed merely by observing that the original photograph was available on Instagram“, because “the issue is the alleged misuse of that photograph, the association of her identity with the obscene video, and the subsequent circulation of the material and her contact details”.

The alleged conduct, if established, would “adversely affect her dignity and privacy as a woman”, the order said.

How did the court interpret identity theft?

Section 66C punishes the fraudulent or dishonest use of another person’s “electronic signature, password or any other unique identification feature”.

The court applied this provision by observing: “In the present case, it is the identification or the facial identification of the person which has been used, as also, the Instagram handle of the respondent No.2 has been shared in the various WhatsApp groups with a video showing the same facial features as respondent No.2.”

The order clarifies that its observations are confined to the petition seeking to quash the proceedings. The trial court must decide the case on the basis of the evidence, “uninfluenced by any observation made herein”.

What did the forensic evidence show?

The State Forensic Science Laboratory found that the facial features of the woman in the images and screenshots were “similar”, based on visual observation. It also recorded that it “does not have tools/facility to compare visual content” and that examining whether the files had been edited was “beyond the scope” of its audio-video section.

The government pleader told the court that the laboratory “did not have the facility to verify” the material.

The court said that determining whether the person in the video was the complainant was “a disputed question of fact” that the trial court would have to decide. It held that the forensic reports, recovered files and WhatsApp records together provided sufficient grounds for the prosecution to proceed.

What does India’s data protection law say?

Section 3(c)(ii) of the DPDP Act states that the Act does not apply to personal data that is “made or caused to be made publicly available” by the person to whom it relates or by someone legally required to publish it.

The Act’s illustration refers to a person who, “while blogging her views, has publicly made available her personal data on social media”.

Therefore, this exclusion depends on who makes the data publicly available. A photograph that the woman posted herself would fall outside the Act. If she had not posted the photograph herself or caused it to be made publicly available, it would be considered under the Act.

The language of the Act does not specifically address screenshots or the resharing of publicly available photographs. If the exclusion applies, the person depicted in the photograph would be left without remedies under this Act. Section 3 is due to come into force in May 2027, along with most of the Act.

This leaves such cases within the ambit of criminal law, whose provisions do not specifically account for photographs that are reused or reshared. Section 67 only examines whether the material is obscene; it does not address whether the person depicted in it consented to its use.

Also read: