Republicans’ stunning midterm defeat is forcing them to confront a question that will shape their 2028 primary: Can their next standard-bearer come from inside the Trump administration?

Vice President JD Vance remains the most prominent potential successor to President Donald Trump, but his blunt X post pinning the party’s Tuesday collapse on the Iran war showed he’s aware that it’s a political liability for all Republicans heading into 2028. And concerns about Vance’s viability are brewing in some corners of the GOP.

“The biggest loser Tuesday night, heading into 2028, was JD Vance,” one Republican strategist argued. “2028 shifted from a conversation about who could carry the torch of Trumpism, to who can rebuild the movement from shambles.”

Vance isn’t the only prospective candidate tied to Trump with new problems after the midterms. While former Speaker Newt Gingrich suggested that Tuesday night might have opened a 2028 lane for Secretary of State Marco Rubio — who’s indicated that he has no plans to run — anyone in Trump’s circle could face similar headwinds.

That includes administration officials who are occasionally whispered about as harboring presidential ambitions, like Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth. Semafor spoke with more than a half-dozen Republicans, inside and close to the administration, who are starting to doubt that voters will embrace Trump’s chosen successor.

“It’s an open race, no question about it,” one person close to the White House said of the looming 2028 debate.

Others in the party are focused on an even touchier topic: Are Republicans doomed for 2028, particularly if the war drags on and voters continue feeling the economic effects?

“There are a lot of Republicans who desperately do not want Donald Trump to be the conversation in 2028. But they’re living in a fantasy world — and the reality is, Donald Trump will always be a big part of the Republican conversation,” said a second person close to the White House. “The actual question is: Can any Republican win?”