The original Sonos Ace headphones were solid, but Sonos stepped things up with the Sonos Ace Ultra. These headphones offer better integration with other products in the Sonos ecosystem, but their $450 price is nearly the same as the $460 Sony WH-1000XM6, which have been the go-to premium headphones for some time.

Also: I let ChatGPT run my 7 Sonos speakers – and multi-step commands were the best part

Given that both pairs of headphones are priced similarly, you might be wondering which is better for you. I’ve used both of them extensively since they were released. Ultimately, both have a lot to offer, and there’s no clear winner based on specs alone. That said, there are areas in which one option might be better for you than the other. Here’s a look at the differences between the two pairs of headphones and which you should go for.

You should buy the Sony WH-1000XM6 if…

Sony WH-1000XM6 in Black

Jada Jones/ZDNET

You care about the best audio response

Sony has offered amongst the best audio response in its consumer headphones for a while, and the Sony WH-1000XM6 is a perfect embodiment of it. The Sony headphones have more detail in the high end and a little more refinement, resulting in a slightly better listening experience. That’s certainly not to say that the Sonos Ace Ultra headphones don’t sound good.

Review: Sony WH-1000XM6

On the contrary, they sound very good and a whole lot better than the original Sonos Ace headphones. But the Sony headphones are more precise and agile, while the Sonos headphones are a bit warmer, at least out of the box.

Codecs factor in too. Sony supports LDAC for high-res streaming up to 24-bit/96kHz at 990 kbps, as well as LC3 and LE Audio. Sonos counters with aptX Lossless over Bluetooth from a compatible source, plus lossless playback through USB-C. On an iPhone, both default to AAC and the gap narrows.

You want better ANC

Both pairs of headphones offer pretty good ANC, but the Sony WH-1000XM6 headphones are a step above not just Sonos but everyone else. Again, both of them will do a good job at cutting out things like the rumble of a plane engine or background noise in a city, but when there are less consistent sounds that are closer to you, you’ll find that the Sony headphones excel.

Also: Sony WH-1000XM6 vs. Sennheiser Momentum 5: I prefer this one

That said, the Ace Ultra headphones still have quite good ANC — and like with audio quality — it’s a lot better than the original Sonos Ace. Given how solid it still is, noise cancellation alone probably isn’t a reason to go for the Sony headphones over the Sonos ones, especially since both are so good at it. That is, unless getting the best ANC you can is important to you, in which case the Sony headphones pull ahead.

You want a lighter build

The WH-1000XM6 is lighter than the Ace Ultra, and you can feel the difference when you wear them. To be fair, I was able to wear both for hours at a time without issue, but the Sonos headphones certainly felt heavier on the top of my head.

Also: Sony WH-1000XM6 vs. Bose QuietComfort Ultra (2nd Gen): This one wins

The WH-1000XM6 also restores the folding hinges that Sony dropped on the WH-1000XM5, allowing it to collapse into a significantly smaller footprint. The Ace Ultra’s cups only swivel flat. In practice, they both get reasonably compact, especially given the fact that the Ace Ultra’s earcups are considerably slimmer.

You should buy the Sonos Ace Ultra if…

Jada Jones/ZDNET

You use a lot of other Sonos products

If you already own Sonos speakers or a soundbar, the Ace Ultra does something no other Bluetooth headphones can. Press and hold the Content Key, and whatever is playing on your Sonos system transfers to your headphones. Press again and it goes back. That’s Headphone Linking, the big new feature of Sonos’ Headphone Engine 2 hardware, and it’s the single biggest reason to buy the Ace Ultra over the Sony.

Bose’s SimpleSync is the closest comparison: it will pass soundbar and speaker audio to a pair of Bose headphones, but Bose’s speaker lineup isn’t as well built out as Sonos’.

Review: Sonos Ace Ultra

The original Ace could only swap TV audio with a Sonos soundbar. The Ace Ultra extends that handoff to any compatible Sonos speaker. It also supports TV Audio Swap with compatible Sonos soundbars, native Dolby Atmos with dynamic head tracking, and TrueCinema, a room-calibration feature for private TV listening that requires a compatible Sonos soundbar. All three need compatible Sonos hardware, the Sonos app, and content that supports the format.

The Ace Ultra’s ecosystem premium is easiest to justify as the personal listening endpoint in an existing Sonos home. The cheapest Sonos soundbar supporting TV Audio Swap is the $219 Ray, and linking is only useful if you already own Sonos speakers. If you don’t, this feature is irrelevant, and you’re better served by the Sony.

You want a slim, more premium design

Side by side, the Ace Ultra is the better-looking pair of headphones. Its earcups sit flatter and slimmer against the head than the WH-1000XM6, with metallic detailing and a smooth, curved shape that reads as understated rather than techy. To me, the Ace Ultra looks less bulky. Sonos didn’t overhaul the silhouette for this generation, but the matte finish resists fingerprints well, and it comes in Black, Soft White, Sand, and Agave, the latter probably the most interesting of the four. Sony ships the WH-1000XM6 in Black, Platinum Silver, Midnight Blue, Sand Pink, Sandstone, and Olive Gray.

Also: Sonos Ace Ultra vs. Sonos Ace: Who should upgrade

The Ace Ultra’s ear cushions are also magnetic and user-swappable, with replacement pairs at $39. The battery is replaceable via a $25 kit, though Sonos warns it requires disassembly, tools, and “some time and patience.” Over a five-year ownership span, a replaceable battery can seriously come in handy. Sony’s WH-1000XM6 ear pads are also user-replaceable without tools, and Sony uses recycled plastic in multiple components. Sonos goes further with the replaceable battery, recycled materials, and plastic-free packaging.

You need a longer battery life

Sonos rates the Ace Ultra at 35 hours with ANC or Aware mode on. Sony rates the WH-1000XM6 at 30 hours with ANC on. Five hours with ANC active is a reasonable gap. Sure, if you’re good at charging, it might not make much of a difference in day-to-day use, but if you’re not, it might make a big difference. Both promise up to three hours of playback from a three-minute charge.

Review: Sonos Beam Ultra

The Ace Ultra takes about three hours to fill from empty, and both can be used while charging over USB-C, though the Ace Ultra supports USB-C audio while the WH-1000XM6 doesn’t.

Writer’s choice

If I could only keep one pair, I’d keep the Sony WH-1000XM6. The WH-1000XM6 sounds more detailed, cancels a wider range of noise, and is lighter on my head over the course of a long day. Again, the Sonos Ace Ultra headphones are great, but their biggest advantage comes from the ecosystem rather than the areas where Sony wins.