Dh2.6 billion in net transfers

The court accepted unchallenged accounting evidence that Dh4.183 billion was transferred into Shetty’s personal bank accounts during the period examined. The claimants listed more than 500 transfers, most from NMC Group accounts at Bank of Baroda into three accounts held by Shetty at the same bank.

Some money was transferred back to NMC. After accounting for those transfers, the judge said, “the net value of the Direct Shetty Payments was some AED 2.6 billion”.

The judge also found that Shetty “knowingly acquired with funds so transferred personal assets and investments”. These included Travelex, a share in an aircraft, Dubai Hills properties and a Wyoming oil investment, according to the judgment.

The aircraft was a Gulfstream G450 that Shetty and Puthan N C Menon jointly acquired for private use under an equal partnership arrangement agreed in July 2014. The judgment also identified NNMC as a vehicle for other acquisitions, with Shetty as its sole shareholder and Shetty and Manghat as its directors.

On Manghat, the judgment summary stated: “The Court also found that Mr Manghat was a dishonest party to the fraud throughout the Relevant Period”. It said his participation included “knowingly facilitating the unlawful misappropriation of funds from the NMC Group for the benefit of Dr Shetty, himself and others” and “concealing NMC Group borrowings from Ernst & Young”.

Billions in hidden borrowing

The court found that NMC’s total borrowing and undisclosed debt increased annually from 2012 to June 30, 2019. By December 31, 2018, identified unreported debt stood at approximately $3.888 billion, alongside reported debt of about $1.993 billion.

The judgment described how undisclosed borrowing was recorded internally but concealed through changes to accounting records. “It was thus disguised through manipulation of the underlying accounting ledgers, and thereby it was concealed from EY,” the judge said.

The court also examined a sham supplier scheme used to obtain financing through transactions that did not represent genuine supplies. Its findings detailed internal arrangements to maintain separate accounting records as NMC upgraded its systems.

Referring to those changes, the judge said “the fraudsters continued to conceal the fraud by maintaining two sets of books”.

Court rejects defences

Shetty maintained that he knew nothing of the fraud and was himself a victim of wrongdoing by Manghat and other senior managers, the judgment records. Manghat disputed his role and contended that Shetty perpetrated the fraud for his own benefit.

The court found that both men dishonestly participated. It also rejected Manghat’s submission that, despite his job title, he had no oversight of financial transactions and was subordinate to the principal shareholders.

“This is an unlikely submission from a man who was the CEO of a FTSE 100 company, it is inconsistent with the evidence, and I reject it,” Justice Smith said.

The judge found that Manghat made major decisions for NMC and ran its financial and treasury arrangements. He said Manghat had “a leading role, indeed the leading role, in effecting the misappropriations and operating the fraud to finance them and disguise them”.

Justin is a personal finance author and seasoned business journalist with over a decade of experience. He makes it his mission to break down complex financial topics and make them clear, relatable, and relevant—helping everyday readers navigate today’s economy with confidence. Before returning to his Middle Eastern roots, where he was born and raised, Justin worked as a Business Correspondent at Reuters, reporting on equities and economic trends across both the Middle East and Asia-Pacific regions.