LessWrong AI
2026-11-09 03:45 UTC
By Eric Raymond
USR-0152-20261109-community-fo-28bdf32e
All Interesting Behavior Is Overdetermined
This is an essay about individual rationality technique. It's intended to show that "All interesting behavior is overdetermined" is, under a specific meaning of "overdetermined" that is stronger than just "multicausal", a valuable heuristic for generative understanding and the avoidance of error. Scott Alexander's 2018 essay The Omnigenic Model As Metaphor for Life is a clear statement of what has become general rationalist doctrine on multicausality. Scott observed that behavioral genetics was difficult because complex human traits involved far more interacting causes than workers expected. He draws this methodological lesson: “We should go from trying to discover ‘the’ cause, to trying to find out which factors we need to create the best polycausal model.” He applies the same reasoning to depression, intelligence, comma, and other complex psychological phenomena. He explicitly warns against looking for one or ten causes when there might be dozens or hundreds. Scott is, however, talking mainly about contributory causation, when an effect is produced by an accumulation of causes; in his type example, there are probably twenty thousand genes which contribute to intelligence, but no one "intelligence gene". This is not quite the same as overdetermination, which describes a situation in which a complex behavior could be explained with any one of multiple causes, each one in itself sufficient. When we find a sufficient explanation, or a sufficiently good collection of contributo…
This is an essay about individual rationality technique. It's intended to show that "All interesting behavior is overdetermined" is, under a specific meaning of "overdetermined" that is stronger than just "multicausal", a valuable heuristic for generative understanding and the avoidance of error. Scott Alexander's 2018 essay The Omnigenic Model As Metaphor for Life is a clear statement of what has become general rationalist doctrine on multicausality. Scott observed that behavioral genetics was difficult because complex human traits involved far more interacting causes than workers expected. He draws this methodological lesson: “We should go from trying to discover ‘the’ cause, to trying to find out which factors we need to create the best polycausal model.” He applies the same reasoning to depression, intelligence, comma, and other complex psychological phenomena. He explicitly warns against looking for one or ten causes when there might be dozens or hundreds. Scott is, however, talking mainly about contributory causation, when an effect is produced by an accumulation of causes; in his type example, there are probably twenty thousand genes which contribute to intelligence, but no one "intelligence gene". This is not quite the same as overdetermination, which describes a situation in which a complex behavior could be explained with any one of multiple causes, each one in itself sufficient. When we find a sufficient explanation, or a sufficiently good collection of contributo…
Full article content could not be extracted automatically. Read the original below.
Source:
LessWrong AI
· lesswrong.com