The Costco cheesecake was also the only option not specifically marketed as New York-style, but I thought it tasted authentic. It was dense, creamy, and tangy.

The crust also nailed the classic, buttery, graham-cracker flavor. Although it was a little thin for my liking, it held the filling well, which impressed me.

The only drawback was the sugary frosting on top, which felt unnecessary and distracted from the actual cheesecake filling.

However, it was definitely my favorite option overall, and for the price, I thought it was a great value.

This story was originally published on February 26, 2026, and most recently updated on November 10, 2026.