Ultimately, though, this felt like a great value for 10, even after I purchased additional ingredients. As Aldi promised, the cost per person came to about $4 for a whole Thanksgiving feast.
The meal had the perfect amount of turkey, pumpkin pie, cranberries, and rolls; plenty of stuffing; and just enough sweet potatoes and peas for a 10-person party.
Even the veggie tray, strange as it seemed, felt sufficient for a big group.
Overall, I wish Aldi's Thanksgiving under $39 list was a little more transparent about the extra items needed, or at least clearer about what customers should have on hand.
Spending a few extra bucks wasn't a huge deal, but had I not checked the recipes in-store, I would've needed to make another trip to Aldi.
When reached for comment, Aldi provided the following statement, attributed to chief commercial officer Scott Patton:
"We put a lot of thought into this year's ALDI Thanksgiving meal because we know how much goes into hosting the holiday. We took a different approach this year, building the assortment around the same Thanksgiving staples the American Farm Bureau Federation has tracked for 40 years. That's why the items look a little different from last year. We selected ALDI products that meet or exceed the quantities in AFBF's meal, so shoppers may have ingredients left to use beyond the meal. We wanted to give shoppers a classic meal for 10 for under $39 and a meaningful way to compare prices. Over the last five years, ALDI shoppers have saved an average of 26% compared to AFBF's national average. Like the Farm Bureau's benchmark, common pantry staples are accounted for separately, since many of our shoppers already have them on hand. And because every family has its own Thanksgiving traditions, shoppers can add their favorite sides or ingredients while still getting the great quality and low prices they count on from ALDI."