The Madras High Court has held that books of “doubtful taste” include AI-generated and plagiarised works, which public libraries cannot procure, and it has directed the registration of an FIR into alleged fraudulent book purchases in Tamil Nadu. A division bench of Justices G.R. Swaminathan and M.D. Sumathi issued the directions on November 10, 2026, in a contempt petition concerning the alleged violation of an earlier order on library procurement. 

The case stems from a 2019 writ petition filed by S. Krishnan, which raised concerns over the procurement of books under different titles and authors’ names. The court had issued comprehensive directions in June 2024, which it said had not been followed. As an author based out of New Delhi, it is refreshing to see public libraries receive attention; Delhi’s neglected public library system could certainly use some.

AI-generated works fall within ‘doubtful taste’: Interpreting Rule 18(4) of the Tamil Nadu Public Libraries Rules, 1950, the bench said books purchased for libraries must meet standards of general interest and cultural value. Standard authors must write fiction and novels, according to the rule, which also prohibits purchasing books of doubtful taste. The court extended this yardstick to non-fiction as well, requiring selection committees to assess books by first-time authors before procurement.

Standard authors must write fiction and novels, according to the rule, which also prohibits you from purchasing books of doubtful taste

It said the term ‘doubtful taste’ must be construed expansively to include dubious content and false narratives. The bench expressly stated: “AI-generated and plagiarised works also would fall within this ambit.” It added: “Unless such satisfaction is arrived at, such books shall not be procured.” The court said library users are entitled to presume that information in books is authentic.

Copyright, re-publication and false authorship: The court’s earlier June 2024 judgment in S. Krishnan’s writ petition had flagged the re-publication of nationalised books and works whose copyrights had expired under different titles and authors’ names. It cited Veeram Vilaintha Varalatru Puthinangal Part-I, published in 2013, as a copy of Kalki’s Sivakamiyin Sabatham. The judgment also referred to books by writers such as Thiru Vi Ka, A. Sa. Gnana Sambanthan and Na. Parthasarathy that had been republished as recent works. 

The court said that when copyright is nationalised, the government becomes its custodian and must protect the author’s moral right to be identified as the creator. It observed that procuring books falsely attributed to people who had not written them breached this obligation. The order also noted that expired copyright or nationalisation had enabled re-packaging under false titles and covers.

Procurement transparency and digital access: The June 2024 judgment had directed the Director of Public Libraries to maintain a dedicated, user-friendly and functional website for procurement notifications. The court required the shortlisted books’ details and covers to be published on a separate webpage, with one month allowed for public comments and objections. It also directed that these comments remain online and not be deleted. However, the court noted that this was not followed. 

The November 10 order said compliance with these directions could have prevented purchases from publishers the court described as ‘dubious entities’, including Agal Vilakku, Sigma and Phoenix. The court also reiterated that public libraries matter as information platforms, saying that libraries infringe the right to receive accurate and quality information when they stock bogus books with false content or works attributed to phantom authors. It directed librarians to identify and catalogue suspect books and withdraw them from public access.

Also read: