X ‘locked’ Times of India photojournalist’s account after Delhi smog posts: Report
X appears to have briefly locked Times of India (TOI) photojournalist Anindya Chattopadhyay’s account after he posted images of Delhi’s post-Diwali pollution and smog, according to Chattopadhyay’s report in the Times of India. Chattopadhyay said the platform cited a “violation of its rules” when it locked the account. However, at the time of writing this, the account was accessible.
Chattopadhyay said it was his duty to show “the truth of the post-Diwali situation” through his camera. He also wrote that X locked his account after the uploads:
“The scene there was no better. The city’s iconic tombs were barely visible through the dense smog. Concerned by the conditions, I started uploading the photographs and videos to my X account…. My X account was locked after I posted photographs and videos showing poor visibility around NH9 and Lodhi Garden, with the platform citing a “violation of its rules”. – TOI Photojournalist.
Government denies involvement
However, the Delhi government denied any involvement in the lock, as per the TOI report. But the report didn’t disclose whether any other authority sent X a request. It also does not say whether X has responded or restored the account.
What we don’t know
- Which X rule the posts allegedly violated.
- Whether a human reviewer or an automated system took the decision.
- Whether any legal request, under the Information Technology Act or otherwise, preceded the lock.
- Whether the account has been restored.
We’ve emailed X asking these questions, we’ll update the copy once we receive a response.
How this compares with recent cases
Most account restrictions MediaNama has tracked in recent weeks cite a legal demand, not a platform’s own rules. Earlier on October 22, X withheld Polymarket’s account in India in respond to a legal-demand notice. Later in that month, Instagram restricted Khurpench’s account, an anonymous account with around 292,000 followers citing the IT Rules, 2021. The Chattopadhyay lock differs because X pointed to possibly its own rules or policies or community guidelines, since TOI’s report claims that there was no legal notice that stated the sections under which the account was locked.
Recent censorship and takedowns in India
- Jammu & Kashmir’s Kishtwar curbs: On November 3, the district magistrate imposed two-month restrictions on fake news and provocative content, including reaction videos. Officials must also compile a verified inventory of digital news outlets.
- Upper Siang shutdown: Mobile internet was suspended in Arunachal Pradesh hours before a 36-hour anti-dam bandh began on November 2.
- Ila Kazmi’s Instagram block: The journalist’s Instagram account block on September 9 raised questions about the use of Section 79(3)(b) of the IT Act and the role of MeitY’s Section 69A Cell.
- Paranjoy Guha Thakurta’s website: Hostinger briefly took the site down on October 28 over an old NewsClick article. This came days after a Delhi court passed an ex parte order against the seven-year-old article.
- Rakesh Ranjan’s account: Instagram restricted the cartoonist’s account in India on October 27, citing repeated legal takedowns. The notice left key questions unanswered.
- LiveLaw’s reel: Instagram restored a reel made by LiveLaw on an Election Commission of India’s (ECI’s) position in an affidavit before the Supreme Court on October 27, after restricting it over a legal request. However, it remains unclear who made the request, and under which law.
- Reddit’s 26 posts: On October 24, Reddit blocked posts on the India–China border on a government order that names no law. The order’s sender is listed as “redacted”.
- Polymarket’s X account: The account was withheld in India on October 22 in response to a legal-demand, five months after authorities restricted its website.
- Mumbai Police notice to X: On October 18, Mumbai Police asked X to remove 24 posts linked to Sabeer Bhatia’s blocked video on Modi and Adani, citing “false, misleading, and disparaging statements” concerning a “well-known company” in the posts. The request came after the concerned video was blocked on YouTube.
- NIXI and chalosansad.in: The National Internet Exchange of India (NIXI) removed the chalosansad.in website which documented NEET-UG paper leak protests three days. The account was blocked on July 22, just three days after it went live, without notice. On October 14, the Delhi High Court sought responses from the respondents.
Also read
Respond to this