Summary

Maria Isabel Oliveira’s image spread across Brazilian social media, but many omitted her name. Photographers say credit is both a legal duty and crucial for their careers.

PDuring his last campaign event last month, Brazilian President Luis Inácio Lula da Silva stood on the roof of a pickup truck in a crowded avenue in São Paulo followed by his entourage and millions of supporters behind him waving flags and chanting. Lula held the Brazilian Constitution in his right hand and the national flag on the left.

The image was captured by many photojournalists that rode in front of Lula’s truck, capturing every move of what could be the last rally of one of the most influential and consequential presidents in Latin America. But it was Maria Isabel Oliveira, staff photographer at O Globo, who took the photo that best captured the moment for millions in Brazil.

Her photo, posted on her professional Instagram account, quickly gathered more than 19 million views and thousands of likes and comments. Many reposted and shared it elsewhere — and forgot to give credit to Oliveira and her outlet.

“I didn't imagine it would reach this scale, precisely because it wasn't an unprecedented scene. On the other hand, I was very scared and felt invalidated. There were people selling prints of the photo for 28.40 reais (about US$5.50) online, printing it on T-shirts, and public figures used the photo on their social media without crediting me”, Oliveira told LatAm Journalism Review (LJR).

Brazilian copyright law requires third parties to include a photographer’s name with their photos, but it’s not always enforced. Oliveira said other photographers had similar experiences during the elections, like her Belo Horizonte-based colleague Richard Silveira and São Paulo-based photojournalist Tuane Fernandes, whose photo of Lula was featured on the cover of The Guardian Weekly and later also appeared on T-shirts being sold online.

The episode captures a paradox of photojournalism in the digital age: Many photographers dream of taking a picture that captures a historic moment and becomes iconic, but when it happens, the image can take on a life of its own while the photographer’s name is lost along the way.

The cost goes beyond a missing byline. Photojournalists say that credit is important for showcasing their professional skills and helping them secure new assignments and better compensation.

“It's not like ‘hey, I'm promoting your work. Look how cool,’” said Silveira, who also saw one of his images of Lula get circulated online without credit, in a recent video to his Instagram followers. “When you're just making a post, it's fine to post it on your social media. But using the photo for editorial or commercial purposes needs to respect this licensing and compensation.”

Capturing history

Oliveira explained how she took the photo. Brazil’s national anthem was playing and everyone was visibly moved when Lula lifted himself up and stood on top of the truck, she recalled.

LULA TO WRAP UP 2026 CAMPAIGN ON AVENIDA PAULISTA / Maria Isabel Oliveira / O Globo.

“I knew that at some point, the security guard would hold his feet so he wouldn't lose his balance. I didn't want to capture that moment. I wanted to capture him there, free, standing, alone”, Oliveira said. “I knew that at some point he would look up to the sky, because they always look up to the sky. And whenever he does that, his eyes shine. And you can see that most of the time, he's tearing up, he's very emotional. So I waited for that moment, too.”

Oliveira said she knew she had taken a great picture but didn’t consider it unique since many of her colleagues were photographing the same scene. She was surprised when her photo started trending on Instagram. As the shares and views grew to millions, she noticed her credit got lost.

“I believe it all started with the page of an independent media outlet, which took my photo without my permission, edited it, and didn't give credit. After that, everything got out of control,” she said. “Outlets used it without credit and altered the image, even after I didn't respond to their messages asking me for the image in high resolution. I thought it was absurd for them to ask me for that. Artists who claimed to be fighting for democracy used it without credit and without talking to me. A soccer player posted a photo wearing a T-shirt with my photo printed on it.”

Oliveira said many users ignored her when she reached out asking them to give her credit. Some even questioned if the photo was hers, even though the image was first posted on her professional profile.

The last straw, she said, was when a follower sent her a video of a person printing her photo without any permission or credit. After that, a colleague started a movement to publicly acknowledge Oliveira. Others went searching for creditless photos on social media and tagged the photographer.

Deborah Linhares, who posted a video about Oliveira’s photo and the importance of such images in understanding history, said that when a photo reaches millions without credit, the person behind it is cut off from the public recognition they deserve.

“There is someone behind the photo that was there making choices, taking risks, and casting an intentional eye on that event. Giving credit to the photographer means respecting the intellectual work and also the responsibility involved, which is essential for understanding the importance of the image and contextualizing that historical record,” she said.

The São Paulo Association of Photojournalists and Cinematographic Reporters in the State of São Paulo (Arfoc SP) also chimed in. “The reach of an image does not make it content that is free to use, nor does it authorize its indiscriminate reproduction. Each image requires work, knowledge, and professional resources,” the organization said on its Instagram account.

Arfoc’s Rio de Janeiro President Alberto Jacob Filho said sharing images without credit became commonplace with social media. The association often files protests for copyright violations and advises photographers on how to seek compensation for improper use of their work, but Filho acknowledged it cannot be done for every case because of the sheer volume of cases. “Since violations [like this] are common, occurring almost daily, we only take action when the photograph has some level of significance,” he said.

When asked how viral photos can preserve their credit, Oliveira said she is still searching for an answer to that question.

“I even joked with friends in the field that we should get alerts on our phones that our photos are being stolen,” she said. “My consolation is knowing that the truth always comes out in the end, and no one can take away the authorship of the work from you.”