Gurugram desperately needs someone to electrify its shiny utopia more efficiently than public utilities seem able. A little-known founder of hospital chain Medanta says he’s up for the challenge. The city doesn’t want him, after saying it does. 

In popular imagination, Gurugram is the free-marketeer’s fever dream—privately planned, gatekept, flashy. Its marquee builder, DLF, for example, owns and operatesThe Indian Express many more highrise-appropriate hydraulic ladders than the fire department. Yet, the city envies its neighbour’s functional public services and desires more state-led urban development. You need only look at the much-lauded Delhi Metro Rail Corporation, and its timely rescueThe Times of India of Gurugram’s ailing Rapid Metro, to see why. There’s one public service in the city, though, that could do with a more laissez-faire approach. 

Haryana’s electricity distribution companies are in better financial healthMinistry of Power, Government of India than their counterparts in most other states, but lack in service quality. So, unlike the capital city next door, Gurugram relies on expensive diesel generators—over 3,900The Times of India by last count—to see it through hot summers and cold winters. 

“With the number of sets they must acquire, real-estate developers have to behave almost like power distributors,” notes Gauri Jauhar, executive director at the market consultant S&P Global. 

This was the pulse that Sunil Sachdeva—the suit behind Dr Naresh Trehan’s scrubs at Medanta—put a finger on. After months of negotiations with Haryana’s electricity regulator, his year-old distribution company, Eleven Power, received the nodBusiness Standard in late October to serve the districts of Gurugram and Nuh, alongside the public utility DHBVNL. But now, like private players elsewhere in the country seeking to break state-mediated monopolies, Eleven Power finds itself in a tug-of-war to make Gurugram one of a handful of regions where public utilities compete for consumers with private players. 

Facing protests by workers of public utilities, the state government invokedThe Hindu BusinessLine a seldom-used law to ban private-sector parallel-distribution licences, effectively vetoing the regulator’s decision and prompting Sachdeva to approach the courts for remedy.