MAPLE was recently criticized for being a “high-control group” by Kyle Hubbard. [1] This is my case that contrary to those criticisms, MAPLE is doing something fundamentally both neglected and highly needed within the realm of x-risk. I’ll make the case in three parts. First, I’ll argue that there is a fundamental bias that causes the perpetuation of x-risk, that is ignored and neglected by the mainstream x-risk community to its detriment. Second, I’ll argue that there is a solution to that fundamental bias, which is based on spiritual attainment in the context of monastic traditions, especially Buddhist traditions. And I’ll argue that what's needed is a new monastery that can address the problems of THIS age, such as artificial intelligence. Finally, I’ll argue that MAPLE is doing a great job of being this monastery, and the harsh criticisms of it are spurious or confused. In that final section, I’ll both directly respond to some of the criticisms made by Kyle, as well as try to provide my perspective on what’s happening here. However, the arguments in that section rest on the two before it, and I urge the reader not to skip ahead. For context, I’ve been a resident at MAPLE for over five years, including time as Head of Operations, and I’ll be leaving in a few months. So I’ve seen how the place works from the inside, and I don’t need anything from MAPLE going forward. From a selfish perspective it would be easier for me to stay silent than to write something controversial t…

Full article content could not be extracted automatically. Read the original below.