LessWrong AI
2026-11-16 02:20 UTC
By AnnaSalamon
USR-0152-20261116-community-fo-2da5ba8b
Why so many arguments about human nature?
Leans fairly heavily on: Believing In Epistemic status: Straightforward, I think, but could use checking. People have long had heated arguments about various aspects of human nature, such as In what ways is or isn’t it human nature to care about others? Are humans innately monogamous or polyamorous? Is it natural to us to sleep for eight hours in a block at night, or to have some particular other rhythm? and piles of others. I would like to enter these arguments soon, by arguing that in a particular sense we are not “optimizers,” and giving a model of what I think we are instead. But before that, in this post, I’d like to discuss why such arguments get so heated to begin with. The heatedness of these arguments used to confuse me, because: If there is “a” human nature, figuring out what it is should maybe be a straightforward matter for pooling data, rather than for politics? If there isn’t “a” human nature, what are people even arguing about? Either way, maybe the amount of politics around this question ought to indicate that it is “off” in some way, and if so, why do people keep arguing about it instead of noticing that it is “off” and losing interest? Humans vary by context "Nature, Mr. Allnut, is what we are put in this world to rise above.” – Katharine Hepburn, playing Rose Sayer, in the movie The African Queen This rock has a shape. I can rotate it, but it retains its shape. A Yoshimoto Cube is a toy that can be arranged into many different shapes. These shapes are inte…
Leans fairly heavily on: Believing In Epistemic status: Straightforward, I think, but could use checking. People have long had heated arguments about various aspects of human nature, such as In what ways is or isn’t it human nature to care about others? Are humans innately monogamous or polyamorous? Is it natural to us to sleep for eight hours in a block at night, or to have some particular other rhythm? and piles of others. I would like to enter these arguments soon, by arguing that in a particular sense we are not “optimizers,” and giving a model of what I think we are instead. But before that, in this post, I’d like to discuss why such arguments get so heated to begin with. The heatedness of these arguments used to confuse me, because: If there is “a” human nature, figuring out what it is should maybe be a straightforward matter for pooling data, rather than for politics? If there isn’t “a” human nature, what are people even arguing about? Either way, maybe the amount of politics around this question ought to indicate that it is “off” in some way, and if so, why do people keep arguing about it instead of noticing that it is “off” and losing interest? Humans vary by context "Nature, Mr. Allnut, is what we are put in this world to rise above.” – Katharine Hepburn, playing Rose Sayer, in the movie The African Queen This rock has a shape. I can rotate it, but it retains its shape. A Yoshimoto Cube is a toy that can be arranged into many different shapes. These shapes are inte…
Full article content could not be extracted automatically. Read the original below.
Source:
LessWrong AI
· lesswrong.com